Bryce's Radio Experiments
The Intersection of PDAs, Wireless, Radio, and CSS.

Permanent Link Sunday, September 01, 2002

Matt Mower: Licensing: My brain hurts

I've had conflicting opinions about the merits of going open source for my liveTopics program.  Before I make a final decision I want to really understand what I am doing either way and what I am, potentially, giving up.

Matt has been openly struggling with using the GPL for liveTopics, and how that decision will affect any future commercial efforts on his part.

I don't care for the GPL, mostly because it is horribly complex and non-intuitive. In the context of Radio/Frontier, it seems that the GPL did not envision complex interpreted environments and frameworks that stretch the concept of "linking" and inherently co-mingle code. Consider the following GPL FAQ entries, how they apply to a GPL'd tool in Radio, and how they might affect a non-GPL'd Radio tool accessing functionality exposed by a GPL'd tool:

A GPL'd Radio tool probably needs a slew of exceptions in order to be used in Radio and by non-GPL'd Radio tools. The LGPL might address this, but I find it equally difficult to understand.

4:59:30 PM | Comments: | Topics: gpl livetopics open_source radio 


© Copyright 2003 T Bryce Yehl Click here to send an email to the editor of this weblog.
Last update: 6/29/2003; 9:38:38 PM.
the